I believe Abby is a mystic, but only out
of desperation. His mysticism is that he will surrender himself to nature to
achieve enlightenment. Abby’s mysticism is like his last hope. He is a loyal servant
to the desert out of devotion, but his hope to attain knowledge is desperation
to make his more human part fully understand and merge with nature, and to pass
on that same knowledge and hope to human society so they will protect nature.
It is obvious from the very beginning
Abby wishes to be a guardian for nature. On one of his first nights working in
arches he says, “I wait and watch guarding the desert, the arches, the sand and
barren rock, the isolated junipers and scattered clumps of sage surrounding me
in the stillness and simplicity under the starlight” (Abby 12). He is clearly
very protective of all the parks elements. He also calls it his “garden”, and
goes on multiple rants about the protection of national parks, natural
predator, circle of life, and the destruction he witnesses in human society. He
makes it clear that he identifies more with nature and less with humanity.
While describing himself he explains, “There are mountain men, there are men of the
sea, and there are desert rats. I am a desert rat” (239). Notice he doesn’t
call himself a desert man, but a rat. He then goes on to explain the leisurely
exploration, and long-term inhabitance, and the rebellion against human
assimilation that only the desert allows for (240). Basically he is saying he
wants to live in and explore the desert, the least humane or all environments.
His characterization of himself as a rat mixed with these desires shows a
willingness to dissolve into nature. Not only does Abby want to inhabit nature
but he also wants to leave humanity. After seeing a human made damn flood the
Glen canyon Abby says, “In these hours and days of dual solitude on the river
we hope to discover something quite different, to renew our affection for
ourselves and the human kind in general by a temporary, legal separation from
the mass” (155). This separation comes from his disappointment in humanity he
cannot identify with societies cause. His frustration leads him to retreat into
nature. He them goes on to describe a sort of rebirth into nature as they get
further away from the dam strengthening the point that he want to be reborn as
a part of nature instead of a human.
Abby describes his mysticism and pursuit
of knowledge as one of the reason he came here in the first place. He describes, “I dream of
a hard and brutal mysticism in which the naked self merges with a
non-human world and yet somehow survives still intact, individual, separate.
Paradox and bedrock” (6). Abby’s description of his mysticisms is to merge with
nature and be reborn. He describes a certain understanding of nature one would
gain free of scientific categories, but yet objective. Abby says he would
“[risk] everything human in [himself]” for this (6). He goes on to apply this hope
to all of society a little later he explains that he appreciates Alaska even
though he’s never been because he thinks “We need the possibility of escape as
surely as we need hope” (129). He is describing nature as this refugee an
instinctual home to run away to. We need this escape and hope to hold when we
desire to lose ourselves in it and escape from society when it gets too awful
and too destructive to bare anymore. Abby is saying that at some point we will
join him and his mysticism desperate to escape from society, and find an
enlightenment on nature. He is saying we need to protect and recognize nature so
it’s there when we need it. His mysticism is born from his devotion to nature and
inability to identify with society. His mysticism of becoming one with nature
sounds farfetched because it is. Even Abby knows this, but he continues to have
hope because a deeper understanding and rebirth into nature seem to be his only
options in escaping society.
The first sentence is excellent. The rest of the paragraph is ok - you could have explained/developed this thought a little more clearly in a little less space.
ReplyDeleteYour 2nd paragraph is good. Even in this draft I would have liked to see you broaden your scope a little to include his contradictions (for instance, the return to NYC at the end). Certainly in a revision I'd expect you to treat him in greater complexity. That doesn't mean you would ultimately deviate from these conclusions - you just want to avoid oversimplifying.
"His mysticism is born from his devotion to nature and inability to identify with society. His mysticism of becoming one with nature sounds farfetched because it is. Even Abby knows this, but he continues to have hope because a deeper understanding and rebirth into nature seem to be his only options in escaping society. " -- this is smart material. I think a deeper, wider use of material in the book will help to pin down what you're talking about and to convince us of it. One question that I have is whether you think his mysticism is ultimately fake - that he pretends either to us or himself to be what he isn't, simply because he's so saddened by the things we've done. Or do you see it as a *true* mysticism which is simply born out of desperation and despair? It's possible that neither one of those is quite right - my point is that you have a great idea which isn't yet carefully pinned down. Because your use of the text is limited and selective, you haven't *had* to pin it down - but I think by exploring one of the more mystical moments or themes in the book (my choice, although not necessarily yours, would be the recurrent use of the Juniper tree and/or of the vultures) you could help clarify your focus.